How we are raising tomorrow’s adults
An
Essay based on
Detoxing Childhood by Sue
Palmer
Written
by
Marcial
I. Enginco
For
Dr.
Grace S. Koo
Professor,
EDFD 206 Affective Learning
SUMMARY
Toxic Childhood is a book written
by Sue Palmer that details her observations and concerns about how today’s
children are growing and developing in a society that does not promote healthy
values, views and attitudes through the improper and often misguided use of
technology, compounded by a “me-first, me-now” lifestyle as dictated by market
forces, and shifts in familial and social structures as an unintended offshoot
of inconsistent parenting and growing gender equality in the family and society.
The book examines the toxic
elements that critically affect a growing child’s learning and development in
areas such as play, diet, education, care, communication and behavior. The essay Detoxing Childhood contains a
letter Palmer and a lobby group of more than a hundred experts and academicians
signed to petition readers, especially governments, educators and society in
general, to train their sights on issues
raised in the book, with the end view of starting a discourse intended to find solutions
to the same.
Palmer is a writer, broadcaster and
consultant specializing in children’s education. She is, according to her words, a cockeyed
optimist.
_____________________
At no point in mankind’s history
has living been more convenient for humans than now, where everything –
including knowledge, food, even happiness or at least how it is defined by
today’s generation – can be had at the click of a finger. The leaps in technology over the past two
decades have radically changed society and the lifestyles that govern the
mainstream that it has practically ensured that the generation being raised
now, those in the age range of 1 to 25 (or those who have opened or will open their
eyes to the internet age), will grow into a breed of adults that no one has
ever seen before. And I am not excited
to find out how they would fare once they take the rein.
Or maybe, that is just me – having
grown at a time when man was transitioning from reading books by flipping pages
to scanning the world by rolling the mouse, I, perhaps, am simply caught
between the nostalgia of my growing years and the present reality that is
strange and largely different from what I was used to. Or maybe, and I strongly suspect, that I have
a legitimate concern that needs to be addressed not by just me, or the
teachers, or parents – but the society as a whole, working as a community to
undo the entanglements that modern living has unwittingly inflicted on our
children.
A lot of the issues that Sue Palmer
raised in her book Toxic Childhood, from which she based her essay Detoxing
Childhood, strongly resonates with observations I routinely make of how today’s
children think, act and behave, and how parents ignore, tolerate and even
enable such behavior.
For one, Palmer points out and I
concur that a child’s normal brain development is not just ready to absorb and
process (with emphasis on process) all the information that adults bombard him
even before he could utter his first word.
The rapid advancement in technology and its ready availability has a lot
to do with this. To illustrate this
point, a video recently circulated on Facebook showed a toddler deftly
operating an iPad, and when she was handed a glossy paper magazine, she
promptly moved her fingers over the page as if it was a touchscreen. I know that it was just a harmless,
meaningless video posted by proud parents but it is an indication that kids are
growing more intelligent by the generation, which is not bad at all if this
rapid intellectual maturation is equaled in pace by parallel emotional, social
and psychological developments. This,
however, is not so. I know a lot of
kids, from three to preteens, whose idea of play is swiping their fingers
across a flat, lifeless screen. And we
adults marvel at how children are so quick to adapt to hi-tech without
acknowledging that we are compromising their motor skills development which is
best honed by physical plays like running, jumping, sliding, crawling and kicking,
to name just a few traditional but neglected activities. What’s even more alarming is that these children
miss out on actual, face to face, interaction with other kids or playmates
which serve as the basic foundation for inter-personal communication and
relationship-building. It is interesting
to note that the more technology-savvy the kids I know are, the less willing
and capable they are of sustaining social interaction even with family, and
more so with strangers.
It does not help either that
parents, as Palmer also pointed out, are increasingly becoming risk-averse. Many busy parents view any form of activity
that would expose their children to any foreseeable physical or emotional harm
should be avoided at all cost, and that situations such as bullying or
altercations where children’s physical, emotional and intellectual vulnerability
are surreptitiously or deliberately exposed, should be dealt with a combination
of livid protestations and a protective blanket rather than treating it as an
opportunity to equip the young with the necessary tools to face and overcome
adversity by explaining to them what the incident was actually about and what
they could do in such situations. No one
is ever going to avoid adversity in his lifetime. I shudder at the thought of future adults
cowering from a problem and looking for solace that is not coming. And I shudder more when I think that these
adults will be tasked to shepherd the generation after them.
A related article which recently appeared
in Time Magazine entitled “Me Me Me Generation” characterized today’s youths --
which author Joel Stein called Millennials-- as a lazy, narcissistic and
entitled batch. Contrary to Palmer’s
assertion that today’s children are angst- driven, Stein describes them as rather
free-spirited, and less prone to moping or contemplating unhappy thoughts,
which my personal observations tend to support.
This kind of passive behavior, I would like to conclude, is a result of
the way these children are raised by over-protective parents in a world where
everything should be ready and available at the click of a button. I see this pattern of attitude a lot in the
college students who use my wall climbing facility for their Physical Education
classes. While a lot of them look
physically fit for such a vigorous activity, a majority of them would rather
sit at one corner and mingle with one another than engage in an exercise that
would leave them tired, sweaty and sore all over, never mind the sense of
accomplishment that comes with achieving something out of one’s hard work. The value of hard work and the strength of
determination seem to be alien and unimportant concepts to these kids who are
so used to the reset button and thus, not worth the effort to discover and
experience. To their credit, they
diplomatically turn down the adults’ effort to impart such life-defining traits
by smiling and politely saying, “Sir, nakakapagod” before turning to their
gadgets to play their preferred games.
I don’t know if this is the kind of
spirit that should carry humankind forward into the unknown future.
So what can be done to stem the
tide? There is no one single
solution. But I know that it should
extend beyond Palmer’s recommendation that society questions and debates about
child-rearing in the 21st century so that insights extracted from
such discourse can be infused in future policies to address the issues.
Some solutions are so obvious and so
fundamental that they are ignored because they are so. To look forward, one must look back at some of
the old practices that have been proven to shape truly well-rounded children. I
admire parents who have the confidence to keep technology away, instead
allowing children to learn the old way – by reading and experiencing, to
explore their creativity and discover their potential by dabbling,
experimenting and questioning outside of the house, and to grow and gain
physical strength by running, playing and, if it can’t be avoided, falling and
failing.
To this end, parents should be made
to understand, not only by schools but also the government, the gravity and
impact of their roles in tempering the onslaught of technology and modern
lifestyle in the personality development of an entire generation. Adults should themselves step back, slow down
and assess what truly matters to them, and what values they want their children
to have. Society has dictated that
happiness, though fleeting, comes with a price tag and preferably, very
quickly. Such emphasis on the instant
has rendered value-formation market-driven.
Nothing is easy. And that’s the beauty of living, at least in
the age I grew up in. While the rapid
developments and breakthrough in technology will no longer be abated, we the
adults can still do something about how it impacts the youth, and how modernity
should complement and enhance a child’s development, and not allow it to take
over their lives completely.
Palmer considers herself as a
cockeyed optimist. I, too, am an
optimist. But my eyes are open and they
blink and squint because they see that the signs are ominous – a new generation
will be taking over the world, one that was raised by a generation of parents who
care and mean well but simply just don’t have the benefit of a manual on how to
raise 21st century children.
Parents and adults now, I think, are simply overwhelmed by how fast
things have changed, and are thus left aware of what’s happening to their
children but powerless to do anything about it, like a deer crossing a road
that has become immobile because its eyes caught an oncoming car’s headlight.
Until the next generation discovers
how ill-prepared they were to face tomorrow’s complex adversities can they truly
comprehend the problem and its consequences, and in the process painfully acquiring
the knowledge and experiential wherewithal to formulate solutions based on
known variables. I suspect that the children
being raised today by a minority of parents who believe old school is still the
best pedagogy will be most suited to steer their way emotionally, socially and
psychologically across the labyrinthine landscape of the future, and that the children
who are today allowed to wander aimlessly into unknown terrain will look up to
them for guidance, leadership and how to raise children the old fashioned way. Then, the next generation will be in better
hands.